Digital twins in healthcare typically model healthcare assets, personnel, workflows, and behaviors that can enhance problem-solving, decision-making, and the efficiency of care delivery and administrative operations. By simulating real-world entities and scenarios, such as patient flow and care pathways, healthcare organizations can test different conditions and inputs to identify improvements. The benefit of digital twins lies in their ability to analyze changes without disrupting services or compromising patient safety. Partnering with a trusted healthcare software development company is the first step to adopting digital twins technology.
Healthcare organizations employ technology consultants to implement innovative digital solutions and improve patient care. Gartner forecasts that by 2025, a quarter of healthcare organizations will have incorporated structured digital twin programs into their digital transformation plans.
Benefits of digital twins in healthcare
Digital twins enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of care delivery and administrative operations by allowing healthcare providers to test scenarios and predict outcomes without disrupting actual services. The key benefits include:
1. Personalized treatment and improved patient outcomes: DTs enable personalized patient care by creating individualized digital replicas that simulate patient-specific treatment responses. By tailoring treatment plans, healthcare providers can improve patient outcomes and minimize side effects.
2. Improved care coordination: DTs help integrate various healthcare data into a single platform, including electronic health records, imaging, and wearable data. It facilitates seamless healthcare coordination across different providers and enhances patient monitoring and follow-up.
3. Enhanced patient engagement: A digital twin can help patients understand their health conditions and treatment options. Health outcomes are improved due to increased engagement and adherence to treatment plans.
4. Preventive care: DTs can provide personalized wellness and preventive care recommendations by integrating data from wearables and fitness devices, which helps healthcare organizations promote healthier lifestyles and reduce long-term healthcare costs.
5. Reduced surgical risks: By simulating surgeries in a virtual environment, DTs help surgeons plan and practice complex procedures, reducing the likelihood of errors during the actual surgery and improving patient safety.
6. Enhanced decision-making and predictive analytics: Real-time data from DTs provides healthcare professionals with predictive insights, which enhances decision-making related to treatment planning, surgery, and preventive measures. As a result, diagnoses can be made more accurately, and healthcare quality can be improved.
7. Operational efficiency and resource optimization: DTs can simulate hospital management processes to optimize resource allocation, including bed availability, medical equipment, and staff utilization. During high-demand periods, such as pandemics, this ensures that resources are utilized efficiently.
8. Predictive maintenance for medical devices: DTs can be used to monitor the performance of medical devices in real time, predicting maintenance needs before failures occur. This ensures the reliability of critical medical equipment, reducing downtime and enhancing patient care.
9. Virtual clinical trials: DTs enable virtual clinical trials, significantly reducing the time and costs involved in traditional trials. This is particularly beneficial in rare diseases or cases where patient recruitment is challenging.
10. New business opportunities and revenue streams: Implementing DTs can open new avenues for healthcare businesses, such as offering digital health coaching services, precision medicine, and personalized healthcare plans. This helps differentiate their offerings and attracts more patients.
Overall, implementing digital twins in healthcare businesses helps improve efficiency, reduce operational costs, enhance patient outcomes, and create new growth opportunities, ultimately transforming the way healthcare is delivered.
Real-world applications
The use of digital twins in healthcare is steadily expanding, with applications ranging from hospital management and care coordination to medical device design and patient monitoring.
Hospital management and care coordination
Digital twins in healthcare have been used to create digital representations of medical data, hospital environments, human physiology, and staff operations. Their applications include optimizing resource utilization, managing workflows, and enhancing patient care. DTs have been used for elderly and dementia care, such as the DTCoach, for person-centered coaching during the COVID-19 pandemic. They also support remote healthcare, such as AI-assisted telerehabilitation. Partnerships like Siemens Healthineers and GE Health have advanced DTs to optimize hospital efficiency by simulating changes, tracking resources in real time, and providing predictive models to mitigate resource shortages during crises like COVID-19. The latest DT technologies offer real-time displays for early interventions, improving patient safety and preventing errors.
Medical device design
Digital twins are being used for medical device design by creating customizable virtual models of organs. Notable projects include Dassault Systèmes' "SIMULIA Living Heart" in collaboration with the FDA, which developed a virtual twin of the human heart for studying drug interactions and accelerating cardiac device design. In Europe, FEops combines heart DTs with AI for managing structural heart disease, including procedure planning and follow-up for devices like TAVI and LAAO, with clearance in multiple regions. DT models have also been extended to other organs, such as the lungs, to predict ventilation needs and optimize outcomes during the COVID-19 pandemic, as seen in the "Project BreathEasy." The long-term goal is to develop a DT of the entire human body, which could improve personalized medical interventions and resource management in healthcare.
Biomarker and drug discovery
Digital twins enhance biomarker and drug discovery, addressing the challenges of high costs, time consumption, and high attrition rates in conventional drug development. With machine learning, DTs and computer-aided drug discovery (CADD) approaches optimize high-throughput screening for ADME-Tox properties and accelerate the drug discovery process. Examples include the development of HIV-1 inhibitors, anti-cancer agents, and antibiotics using in silico techniques. Collaborations between companies like Atos, Siemens, and GSK have optimized drug manufacturing processes using DTs, while Takeda Pharmaceuticals has adopted DTs for production, aiming to reduce drug development cycles and improve efficiency.
Biomanufacturing
Digital twins in biomanufacturing enhance the efficiency of producing biological products such as medicines, vaccines, antibacterials, and tissues by leveraging naturally occurring processes at a commercial scale. Companies like In Silico Biotechnology AG and Teva Pharmaceuticals have used DTs for predictive biomanufacturing, integrating multi-scale models to optimize production processes by adjusting key parameters like temperature and pH. Supported by IoT, AI, and other advanced technologies, DTs are used to achieve better yields and improve the quality of bioproducts. DTs also contribute to the pharmaceutical sector by simplifying complex manufacturing processes with technologies like AI and robotics, aligning with Industry 4.0's goal of innovative, customized production while maintaining efficiency and reducing labor.
Surgical planning
Digital twins in surgical planning help surgeons simulate procedures before the actual surgery, reducing the risks of errors. DTs like HeartNavigator are used for virtual simulations of transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) to optimize surgical approaches for cardiac surgery. In orthopedics, DTs assist in selecting optimal stabilization methods and post-operative treatments based on individual patient characteristics. DTs are also used to simulate the impact of medical implants, such as vertebroplasty operations, and to predict fracture risks in cancer patients after treatments like stereotactic body radiotherapy, enabling better-informed surgical decisions and treatment strategies.
Virtual clinical trials
In-silico clinical trials (ISTs) and digital twins are emerging as innovative tools to address the challenges of traditional clinical trials, which are costly, time-consuming, and have high failure rates. ISTs use simulation and modeling to support better-powered trials, optimize patient recruitment, and reduce costs, particularly for rare diseases. Digital twins enhance ISTs by predicting individual patient outcomes and improving drug protocols.
Companies like Unlearn.AI use DTs for neurological diseases, while ISTs like the VICTRE study have demonstrated their potential for evaluating medical imaging technologies. Regulators like FDA and EMA support the integration of in-silico approaches, with successful applications in cancer and other diseases using synthetic control arms to expand coverage and gain approvals.
The current landscape of ISTs incorporates multimodal clinical, genomic, and socioeconomic data, and uses AI to iteratively improve trial design and predictions. ISTs hold promise for making adaptive decisions in clinical trials and enhancing precision medicine by predicting patient responses to treatments.
Personalized medicine
Digital twins are advancing personalized medicine by integrating deep phenotyping and digital data to create individualized treatment strategies, particularly in oncology. In precision oncology, DTs help utilize comprehensive genomic profiling (CGP) to identify biomarkers for targeted therapies, though high-level evidence for these biomarkers is often rare. Digital twins combine genetic, clinical, and real-world data (digital phenotype) to personalize care effectively.
DTs have been applied to simulate therapy outcomes for conditions like high-grade gliomas, oropharyngeal carcinoma, and triple-negative breast cancer, helping optimize treatment selections with high accuracy. For non-small cell lung cancer, DTs predicted optimal salvage therapies, showing that pembrolizumab could benefit patients even after disease progression. Collaborative efforts are ongoing to further explore and develop predictive DTs for cancer patient care.
Digital twins for wellness
Digital twins for wellness are being developed to enhance personalized health by focusing on overall well-being rather than specific diseases. Some DTs, like MindBank Ai, offer feedback to improve mental health and well-being. Platforms like Babylon and IBM integrate data from fitness devices and wearables to facilitate patient-doctor engagement and promote personalized healthcare.
Digital phenotyping, a method used to monitor psychological states and health behaviors, is transforming psychiatry and behavioral medicine by enabling real-time interventions for individual wellness. Platforms like Beiwe and Mindlamp are being used for personalized behavioral and psychological interventions. Though full digital twin models of the human brain have not yet been achieved, future advancements in DT technology may enable this.
DT healthcare research centers
Digital twin healthcare research centers have been established to advance DT technology and its applications in personalized healthcare, wellness, disease prevention, diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment. These initiatives involve collaborations between academia, industry, and government to standardize DT methods and ensure interoperability.
Examples of DT centers include:
- Swedish Digital Twin Consortium (SDTC): Focuses on personalized medicine using single-cell RNA sequencing to construct patient-specific DTs and identify effective drugs.
- Empa Research Center: Develops customized DTs to optimize pain medication dosing based on patient data like age and lifestyle.
- Human Digital Twin, OnePlanet Research Center: Collaborates with nutrition and health experts to create AI-guided platforms for analyzing health, nutrition, and behavioral data to suggest personalized lifestyle interventions.
- DIGIPREDICT Consortium: Aims to predict disease progression and early intervention needs in infectious and cardiovascular diseases.
- PRIMAGE: Focuses on personalized cancer diagnosis and prognosis in children using imaging biomarkers and AI to analyze datasets.
- Medical Augmented Intelligence (MAI) DigiTwin: Converts 2D medical images into 3D virtual models for patient engagement and shared decision-making.
- Digital Twin Consortium: Works across multiple industries to develop DT technology, not limited to healthcare.
- Digital Twins for Health Consortium (DT4H.org): Develops DT infrastructure for health, focusing on conditions like lung cancer, sepsis, mental health, diabetes, leukemia, and cardiovascular diseases.
These centers are key in advancing research, improving patient care, and establishing protocols for future healthcare technologies that will drive the growth of digital twins in healthcare market.
Challenges and considerations
Several key challenges, including data quality and integration issues, privacy and security concerns, and implementation challenges, hinder the development of digital twins in healthcare. Addressing these obstacles is essential for realizing the full potential of digital twins in improving patient care and outcomes.
Gathering accurate, real-time data from diverse sources and integrating it into a cohesive model
The main challenge in developing digital twins for healthcare is acquiring and integrating accurate, real-time data from various sources. This includes physiological, biological, and chemical data that can be used to create simulations of disease processes. Integrating data from different sources and formats is difficult due to interoperability issues and the lack of standardized data formats for healthcare. Developing standardized data formats and interoperability standards is essential for constructing effective digital twins in healthcare.
Protecting sensitive patient data while ensuring compliance with regulations
Data privacy and security are major challenges in developing digital twins for healthcare. Building digital twins requires handling vast amounts of sensitive patient data, all of which must be protected from unauthorized access, breaches, and misuse. Compliance with regulations like HIPAA and GDPR adds to the complexity of ensuring data security. Strict measures are needed to protect patient privacy and ensure data encryption, secure storage, and compliance with relevant regulations.
Addressing issues like fragmented data, noise, biases, and missing data
Data quality and accuracy are crucial for developing accurate digital twins in healthcare. Inaccurate or incomplete information can lead to misguided insights. However, accessing comprehensive and high-quality health data can be challenging due to fragmentation across healthcare institutions, noise and biases in data, and the lack of longitudinal data. Ensuring data quality and accuracy requires overcoming these challenges to create effective digital twins.
Ensuring balanced datasets to avoid bias and discrimination in digital twin models
Data bias can be a significant challenge in developing digital twins for healthcare. Digital twins require balanced datasets that represent various demographics and conditions to ensure accuracy. Biased datasets can lead to suboptimal recommendation systems and exacerbate existing healthcare inequalities. Ensuring that digital twin models are devoid of bias or discrimination is crucial.
Obtaining informed consent, addressing data ownership, ensuring patient autonomy, and maintaining healthcare equity
Building digital twins for healthcare raises ethical concerns, including obtaining informed consent, addressing data ownership and control, ensuring patient autonomy, and complying with legal constraints. It is crucial to maintain healthcare equity and avoid exacerbating existing health disparities. Ethical guidelines for data sharing, anonymization, and informed consent must be implemented to foster trust and ethical practices. Ensuring data accuracy and preventing biases in models is also essential to avoid negative consequences for individuals.
Accurately modeling human behavior, body structures, and complex causal relationships
Modeling human behavior and body structures in digital twins for healthcare is complex due to the vast number of dynamic factors and sophisticated causal relationships. Before deploying digital twins in healthcare, ethical considerations and the potential for inequality must be addressed. While digital twins offer significant benefits, they can also exacerbate existing inequalities. Future work will focus on developing multi-scale models that capture measurements across different scales of observation.
Meeting the computational demands of complex digital twin simulations and ensuring data security and privacy
Future advancements in computing infrastructure, such as high-performance computing, Big Data and Analytics, IoT devices and sensors, 5G technology, AR/VR, and blockchain, can increase the accuracy and usefulness of digital twins in healthcare. These technologies can provide processing power, data transfer rates, and security measures to create more complex and realistic digital twin models.
Developing sustainable business models to drive the adoption of digital twin health platforms
For digital twin health platforms to grow beyond academic research, compelling business models need to be developed to create a market in the healthcare industry. While personalized digital twin models have been successful for consumer behavior, their widespread medical adoption may take time. Government and military organizations might be early adopters of digital twin health systems, similar to NASA's use of digital twin simulations for astronauts. These organizations could also use digital twins to monitor soldiers on special missions.
Wrap-up
Digital twins in healthcare offer tremendous potential for medical organizations, but many are unsure how to start. The right technology partner can be instrumental in guiding organizations through implementing digital twins effectively. From defining clear business goals and prioritizing data management to assessing digital maturity and embracing change, a skilled partner can help healthcare organizations make the most of this transformative technology.
N-iX offers a unique combination of deep industry knowledge, data science expertise, VR & AR proficiency, and dedicated development teams. Our experience working with healthcare companies, coupled with our technical skills, allows us to deliver innovative software solutions that address the specific challenges of the healthcare industry. By working with N-iX, healthcare organizations can use digital twins to improve patient outcomes, enhance operational efficiency, and gain a competitive edge.
Have a question?
Speak to an expert
